Pansy’s Most Controversial Book

1 Jun

In 1902 Isabella Alden published her most controversial book, Mara.

Mara is the story of a young woman who unknowingly marries a Mormon man with multiple wives. What made Mara controversial wasn’t the plot. Novels with similar themes of an innocent young woman duped into marrying a polygamous Mormon husband had been published for over 50 years.

Ann Eliza Young-19th Wife of Brigham Young ca 1875 age 31

An 1875 photo of Ann Eliza Young, the 19th wife of Brigham Young, at the age of 31.

Author Metta Victor created the sub-genre with her book Mormon Wives, published in 1856. In the book two women, life-long friends, find themselves married to and betrayed by the same Mormon man.

Cover of the 1890 edition of A Study in Scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle

Cover of the 1890 edition of A Study in Scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle

After that book’s success, an estimated fifty novels were published by 1900, vilifying the Mormon religion. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s book, A Study in Scarlet depicted Mormon President Brigham Young as a villain and the Mormon Church steeped in kidnapping, murder and enslavement of its women.

An 1899 photograph of seven of Brigham Young's Wives

An 1899 photograph of seven of Brigham Young’s Wives

So what made Isabella’s novel Mara different from all the others?

In 1902 when Mara was published, the topic of polygamy was at the forefront of American consciousness. Only a few years before, Americans believed, polygamy had been abolished; they believed plural marriages did not exist because the Mormon Church had assured the Federal Government the practice had been abolished. That assurance had been required of Utah as part of its transition from territory to state.

An 1873 cartoon shows a Union soldier prodding a Mormon man and his wives into the divorce court: "Come, come, get on into the divorce court. This polygamy business is played out. Hereafter you chaps can have only one Polly apiece."

An 1873 cartoon shows a Union soldier prodding a Mormon man and his wives into the divorce court: “Come, come, get on into the divorce court. This polygamy business is played out. Hereafter you chaps can have only one Polly apiece.”

Utah’s transition had been a long and contentious process. The Federal Government had tried numerous ways of outlawing polygamy in the past through the 1862 Morrill Anti-Bigamy Act, and again in the 1882 Edmunds Anti-Polygamy Act. But the LDS Church defied the laws and continued to sanction plural marriage. Under President Grover Cleveland the Federal Government tried to enforce the laws by arresting and imprisoning men who could be proven to be polygamists.

Polygamists in the Utah Penitentiary 1885

Polygamists in the Utah Penitentiary 1885

But the Federal Government’s only effective weapon was blocking statehood, and residents of Utah keenly felt the effects. They couldn’t vote in Federal elections and their territory was ruled by a governor, secretary and judges appointed by the President of the United States.

In 1890 the LDS Church appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing the Edmunds Anti-Polygamy Act was unconstitutional because it prohibited Mormons from practicing their religion, of which plural marriage was an essential part. The U. S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Edmunds Act.

Mormon Church President Joseph F. Smith with his wives and children, circa 1900

Mormon Church President Joseph F. Smith with his wives and children, circa 1900

In 1890 Mormon Church president Wilford Woodruff published his “Manifesto,” which declared an end to the practice of polygamy in the Church. Doing so paved the way for Utah to become a state; and six years later Utah joined the Union. Protestants in America breathed a sigh of relief.

But almost immediately after the Manifesto was issued, certain members of the Mormon Church resumed the practice of polygamy clandestinely. Ranking members of the Church’s Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and other members of the Church entered into plural marriages—and sanctified plural marriages of others—in direct defiance of the Manifesto.

Senator Reed Smoot

Senator Reed Smoot

The rest of the country felt it had been duped and a wave of outrage swept across America. Some believed there was a great Mormon conspiracy to take over the U.S. government. Concern deepened when the Utah Legislature chose Reed Smoot—a member of the Church’s Quorum of the Twelve Apostles—to be the State’s new Senator.

Protestant churches organized massive petitions against allowing Mr. Smoot a seat in the Senate; and the U.S. Senate responded by conducting a multi-year investigation into the Mormon Church and its influence in the state of Utah.

Mara was written in the climate of that time. Like other anti-polygamy novels before, Mara’s plot centered around a young woman who married a successful and gentlemanly man from Utah, only to later discover she was his latest in a string of wives. Mara was also a reminder to readers that America had to remain vigilant in ensuring polygamy as a practice was removed from American society.

Newspaper illustration of Mormon President Joseph F. Smith (seated in the white chair on the right) giving testimony to Senator George Frisbie Hoar during the Reed Smoot Senate Hearing.

Newspaper illustration of Mormon President Joseph F. Smith (seated in the white chair on the right) giving testimony to Senator George Frisbie Hoar during the Reed Smoot Senate Hearing.

Today some might think Mara’s plot is simply sensational fiction; but Isabella Alden’s novels were always rooted in a common truth: her characters lose their way only when their relationship with God wanes. She used the story to show how easy it was for a young woman to fall under a wrong influence in a time of weakness in her life.

In Mara Isabella also displayed some sympathy for the wives and children of the plural unions, which may have been one reason the book came under scrutiny. Some public libraries, including the library in Isabella’s town of Palo Alto, California, banned the book because it dealt with the topic of polygamy, which library trustees considered an immoral practice.

Article in the San Francisco Call on August 1, 1910

Article in the San Francisco Call on August 1, 1910

America, for the most part, did not share Isabella’s pity. Their abhorrence for polygamy (and all who engaged in the practice, including the wives) reached new heights during the four years it took the U.S. Senate to conduct their investigation into practices of the Mormon Church. In the end, the Mormon Church submitted to pressure and outlawed polygamy once and for all, and established a new practice of excommunicating Church members who entered into plural marriages.

Headline about Mormon President Joseph F. Smith's Senate testimony reads "I have five wives, many children, and know that I am violating the laws."

Headline about Mormon President Joseph F. Smith’s Senate testimony from The Salt Lake Tribune, March 4, 1904. His honest, straight-forward testimony shocked America.

Reed Smoot was eventually seated as a United States Senator from the State of Utah. He served his state and his country honorably for almost thirty years, and, by his conduct, helped force a profound shift in America’s perception of Mormonism.

Eventually, Mara was returned to the shelves of the Palo Alto Public Library, but many libraries and stores considered the book too controversial to stock.

Discover more about the events in this post:

Read about Utah’s Road to Statehood 

Read more about Pansy’s Banned Books

The U.S. Senate’s page about The Expulsion Case of Reed Smoot of Utah

Watch a video about Mormon President Joseph F. Smith’s testimony before the U.S. Senate

Read the testimonies of Mormon President Joseph F. Smith and Reed Smoot before the U.S. Senate

Read Mara for free.

Cover_Mara resizedClick on the book cover to read an unabridged edition of the book.

.

.

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Pansy’s Most Controversial Book”

  1. vickyrbenson September 25, 2015 at 1:40 pm #

    This was certainly an eye-opening book. I guess I’m glad I read it, but it struck me as the most depressing novel I have ever read. It seemed to have so many deaths and hardships. It seemed as though everyone’s happiness was snatched away in some way or another. Unrelenting. The most happy time seemed to be Mara’s marriage, which turned out to be a total deceit even though her husband truly loved her (which was also sad, as she felt so betrayed. I had to read the book in stages, but I don’t think I missed anything. It was just too sad for words. It reminded me of Africa, when someone got saved out of heathenism, the missionaries made them put away their extra wives (which I wondered about, especially since they seemed to choose their favorite wife, not necessarily their first wife). It’s really a hard situation with no good solution. It was so horrible that Mara was so deceived. Her husband knew she wouldn’t marry him otherwise. And it all started because she felt she wanted to be baptized for her dead parents, which she never got around to doing. Do you know why that was? I was glad to learn more about Mormons. It was worse than I realized and made me wonder what other clandestine things they still might be doing.

    • Isabella Alden September 25, 2015 at 2:48 pm #

      I had the same reaction to the book, Vicky! Usually, I feel uplifted and renewed and inspired after reading one of Isabella’s books, but this one was a little dark. Even so, I thought it was as well written as any of her books; the scene where Mr. Newland first introduces her to the Mormon practice of baptizing the dead shows how willing Naomi was to believe him. I wanted so much for her to go read her Bible herself and not just rely on what he told her it said! Here are a couple of websites that have good information about the practice of baptizing the dead.
      The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints explains the practice on their website here.
      And this Catholic Church website explains why other Christian religions reject the practice. Scroll down to read the sections titled “The Bible Doesn’t Teach It” and “A Flat Out Contradiction.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Hall in the Grove

Author of Classic Christian Fiction

Isabella Alden

Author of Classic Christian Fiction

Author Jenny Berlin

Stories that take you home

Britt Reads Fiction

Reviews and giveaways for Christian fiction. Bringing readers information on great stories and connecting authors with their readers.

%d bloggers like this: